Hindu Students Say Misinformation In Textbooks Led To Bullying

Sacramento (CBS13) – The state board of education is hearing from hundreds of Hindu students, many of whom say they’ve been bullied because of history lessons that perpetuate stereotypes about their homeland.  So they’re urging educators to change those history books.

Siri Tantry and her friends were raised to be proud Hindus. But in school, they say some kids make fun of them for being part of India’s caste system, which divides Hindus into ranked categories.

ALSO READ: California Education Board Approves 10 Textbook Families, Rejects 2

“They were like, ‘oh you were part of the untouchables right? Are you the Lower class or the higher class?’ And at that moment I got really sad, depressed, frustrated,” said Siri Tantry.

The culprit? Their history books. The girls believe publishers misrepresent their religion and culture by only showing images of trash and poverty.

“I agree there’s negative stuff in each religion, each race in the world, but it’s not fair they exaggerate the negative stuff,” said 8th Grader Aparna Ganabadhi Basavapatna.

“Indians have invented so much. They’ve done so many great things,” said 8th Grader Anwita Satapathy.

They’re asking California educators to approve changes, highlighting India’s positive contributions to the world, from yoga to meditation to math. But scholars say that would only sanitize history.

Stanford Professor of Anthropology Thomas Hansen telling the New York Times, “Our duty is to make sure that the history is keeping with the scholarly research rather than give in to what a particular group wants.”

“We’re not saying that some of these things should not be mentioned, but they should be mentioned accurately with nuance,” said Director at Hindu American foundation Samir Kalra.

Hindu advocate Samir Kalra says he’s not only trying to shape the image of Hinduism, he wants to protect vulnerable Hindu children from bullying.

State educators won’t comment on what changes they’re considering. They’ll vote in November.

More from Steve Large
Comments

One Comment

  1. Ron Banerj says:

    “make sure that the history is keeping with the scholarly research”
    Oh really ??? Good. Then the section on Islam will talk of stoning women to death, sharia law, and female genital mutilation .. RIGHT ?? And will the Catholic section speak of pedophile homosexual priests? OR, is it something different, ie: when it comes to Muslims and Christians, it’s all about those precious snowflakes and their “feelings”.. and when it comes to Hindus, it is about “scholarly research”

  2. I doubt this bullying came from history books. Kids these days DO NOT read them.

    More likely, they got it from YouTube or just your random Google search on Hindus.

    And the books aren’t lying. India really is a messed up place, with incompetent politicians and awful infrastructure. Horrible roads, untreated sewage, and frequent power outages are normal everyday things. It’s a few wealthy and ALOT of poor, with far too many poor living in primitive, unsanitary, barbaric conditions.
    Outside of a few modern cities or office parks, India still is very much Third World, no matter what its apologists may say.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS13 | CBS Sacramento

Get Our App
Get The CBS Sacramento Weather AppGet the latest radar, CBS13 AppCasts and hour-by-hour forecasts. You can also send your weather pics.
Follow Us On Facebook

Watch & Listen LIVE