School District Defends Decision To Deny Student Lunch

LINCOLN (CBS13) — A Lincoln middle-school student was denied lunch after a zero balance showed up on her lunch card.

Daniel Gearhart was outraged when his 11-year-old daughter came home hungry.

“To get up to the lunch line and have your lunch taken away from you because you didn’t have $3,” he said.

And all in front of your classmates. On Friday, Gearhart says it happened to his 6th-grade daughter, a student at Twelve Bridges Middle School in Lincoln.

“That kills you as a parent,” he said.

This is the latest example of a nationwide issue. In California, lawmakers are trying to prevent more cases of what’s called “lunch shaming.”

Gearhart says he loaded $10 into his daughter’s lunch account online as he always does, but when lunchtime rolled around, the balance still said $0. His daughter’s meal was taken away and replaced with one apple and some milk.

“I was immediately angry, calling the school and trying to get answers,” said Gearhart.

According to Western Placer Unified School District, it’s policy.

It released a statement Tuesday saying in part, “If a student does not have lunch money or does not have a balance on their account, they are offered a light alternative, which typically consists of milk or juice and a piece of fruit or snack bar.”

State Sen. Bob Hertzberg (D-Los Angeles) said, “This is just one of these practices that shocks the conscience.”

California is trying to prevent what’s known as lunch shaming. Beginning Jan. 1, a new law will stop schools from treating children whose lunch accounts are past due any differently than those who don’t have money for the day. Hertzberg authored the bill.

“In the meantime, let’s not victimize children for adult issues,” said Hertzberg.

The law still allows schools to serve an “alternative snack” to students who can’t pay and wouldn’t have made a difference for Gearhart’s daughter since she wasn’t in debt, but Gearhart hopes the district will make changes on its own, so no child has to finish the school day hungry.

The new bill will also require schools to notify parents when unpaid fees exceed ten full price lunches. An official with the Western Center on Law & Poverty says there may be a second bill in the future that could ensure kids get a full meal regardless of what their balance or debt is, as long as there is an agreement that parents pay it at a later date.

More from Angela Greenwood
Comments

One Comment

  1. Saddened by the lack of care on the faculty’s part. They had a “glitch” in the online system that day. Therefore, there was no money on her account at lunch time. She was embarrassed in front of the other kids when her lunch was taken from her hands and told in front of everyone you don’t have money you can’t have lunch. How does a grown adult feel doing this to a child. I would love for the staff to have a bowl of cereal at 6 am and go all day until 430pm with eating an apple. Play PE and run around and see how your mind works and how much energy you have! Disgusted to say the least. Have a heart and change your policy.

  2. Sue Brusseau says:

    Was there not one compassionate adult who could have stepped up with a $3 loan? My God, a phone call to the parent might have taken a full 60 seconds, to clarify the problem. I hope many parents will show up to the next school board meeting; let them know loud and clear, this will not be tolerated. Next time it could be your child. What the heck has happened to common sense?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS13 | CBS Sacramento

Get Our App
Get The CBS Sacramento Weather AppGet the latest radar, CBS13 AppCasts and hour-by-hour forecasts. You can also send your weather pics.
Follow Us On Facebook

Watch & Listen LIVE