By Marissa Perlman


FAIR OAKS (CBS13) – A transgender man is suing Mercy San Juan and Dignity Health after being denied a hysterectomy procedure.

The hospital canceled the surgery last minute after the patient, Evan Minton, mentioned to a nurse he is transgender. The lawsuit claims the hospital discriminated against him.

“I knew exactly why they wouldn’t perform this surgery on me,” said Minton.

Evan Minton (credit: ACLU)

Just days before his scheduled hysterectomy, Minton got a call from his doctor.

READ: California Bill Requires Updates To Transgender Students’ School Records

He said, “She told me I have to let you know your surgery has been canceled. She said they won’t let me perform on you because you’re transgender.”

Minton said he was shocked.

He says he chose Mercy San Juan because it was close to his home in Fair Oaks, and also a place his doctor performed hysterectomies all the time.

He said it was his worst nightmare.

“I’m going to have to live with this gender dysphoria for who knows how long, and that’s going to jeopardize my life,” he said.

Elizabeth Gill with the ACLU represents Minton and said the hospital’s actions violated state law, which says businesses must offer equal access to state residents.

“It was only when Evan outed himself to a hospital staff person as transgender, that they abruptly canceled his procedure,” she said.

ALSO: Transgender People Are Not Mentally Ill, The WHO Decrees

Mercy San Juan is a Catholic Hospital with Dignity Health. Dignity Health released this statement in regards to the case:

“Dignity Health has a legacy of providing care to all people regardless of their background, sexual orientation, or gender identity. Our services are available to everyone without discrimination and all are welcome at our care sites. Catholic hospitals do not perform sterilizing procedures such as hysterectomies for any patient regardless of their gender identity, unless there is a serious threat to the life or health of the patient. Courts have repeatedly recognized the right of faith-based hospitals not to provide services based on their religious principles. We are sensitive to the specific health needs of transgender patients and specialty care for trans individuals is offered at many of our care sites. In this case, Mr. Minton was able to quickly receive the sought-after procedure at another nearby Dignity Health hospital that is not Catholic-affiliated.”

Gill said, “All hysterectomies are medically necessary, that’s just a fact. They perform them regularly for CIS-gender women.”

The decision this week returns Minton’s case to San Francisco County Superior Court, which had previously dismissed it.

So why is the lawsuit allowed to move forward, now? An appeals court ruled California’s interest in fighting discrimination outweighs religious standards on healthcare.

“They’re only excluding transgender people from this treatment because the Catholic Church, as a whole, does not recognize the existence of transgender people,” Gill said.

Seventy-two hours after the surgery was canceled at Mercy San Juan, it was able to happen in South Sacramento at Methodist Hospital.

Minton, who works at the capitol, said he had colleagues make phone calls on his behalf.

The next court hearing in the lawsuit has not been set.

Marissa Perlman

Comments
  1. Former Mercy Employee says:

    Actually, Dignity health does NOT perform “hysterectomies on CIS gender patients all the time” without it being indicated for the health and safety of the patient in question. This person isn’t going to die from being denied a hysterectomy. I had my tubal ligation done at MSJMC. I had to be approved by the board of trustees before my doctor could perform the procedure. Due to my heart condition and two pregnancies that made me diabetic and insulin dependent, my tubal was approved. Another woman from my OB/GYN office was in her mid forties with 4 kids and her tubal was denied because she had no medical issues with her pregnancies and was healthy. Dignity also does not perform terminations. This person is going to waste a lot of time and money in court on a useless battle because as Dignity ever so clearly states, this is a faith based hospital and they are protected. Please, go to Sutter for your hysterectomy and stop trying to force people to do things they don’t believe in. You don’t believe you’re a woman, Dignity doesn’t believe in sterilizing people without just medical cause. And no, gender identity doesn’t count here. Sorry.

Leave a Reply