cbs13-cw31 1140 The Fan - 100x35

Local

Shelter Gives Away Dog Marked For Euthanization

Share this
View Comments
Sophie, a cocker spaniel

Sophie, a cocker spaniel

Maria-Medina-Web-Headshot

Reporting Maria Medina

Features

PLACERVILLE, Calif. (CBS13) – A Placer County resident who asked for her dog to be put to sleep because of health problems was surprised to hear the dog was instead put up for adoption.

The El Dorado Animal Shelter made no apologies for seeking a new owner for Sophie, a cocker spaniel, after seeing how playful and healthy the animal seemed.

“We feel like we did the appropriate thing, we saved an animal’s life,” said Animal Services Chief Henry Brzezinski.

The owner told shelter employees the dog needed to be put to sleep because she was suffering from incontinence.

“I had a dog that was incontinent years ago and it’s not a death sentence,” Brzezinski said. “We always evaluate an animal that’s brought into our facilities to see if there’s any chance of adopting an animal out.”

Sophie’s owner claimed she learned her dog was alive when she opened the paper and saw a picture of the cocker spaniel, with the note she was available to a new home. An 81-year-old man responded to the ad and adopted Sophie.

He hasn’t seen any signs of health problems.

“A shelter should really be a last resort for an animal,” Brzezinski said.

The surrender form filled out by Sophie’s owner makes no mention that the shelter tries to save animals given up for euthanization, and Brzezinski acknowledged there are “differing opinions” about whether employees told the owner they would evaluate the dog.

The shelter has never received a similar complaint before and the director says they are reviewing their policies, which may end up adding more information to their surrender forms.

It costs $55 to put a dog to sleep and $40 to give the dog up for adoption; the shelter is refunding the $15 difference to Sophie’s original owner.

The dog’s original owner did not respond to requests for comment.

Share this
View Comments
  • bob bobster

    If an animal is suffering I understand easing the suffering but because it is suffering from incontinence is not right. The same rules we apply for people should apply for animals as they depend on us as their keeper. Would they want themselves put down if they wet their pants?

  • Kai

    Way to go El Dorado Animal shelter. Kudos for saving that sweet puppy and thank goodness for the man who adopeted her!

  • Stephen

    Bless you, El Dorado Animal Shelter, for recognizing this adorable little dog deserved the chance to live! Shame on you, original owner! You do not deserve to own a beautiful such as this one.

  • sasha

    Thankfully El Dorado Animal shelter had the wisdom to give this beautiful puppy a new loving home.

  • crazyplus40

    FANTASTIC… GREAT job El Dorado Animal Shelter!!!!

  • mzvjc1

    Thank goodness for the El Dorado Animal shelter for saving this dogs life and thank God for the person that adopted her. Way to go!

  • Renee

    Awesome job El Dorado Animal Shelter for having a heart!! that lady doesnt deserve a furbaby. Just because the dog appear to have a bladder problem…they have meds for that and there are puppy diapers…if she had a child she would have it put to sleep just because it may have an illness. Treat your pets the same way!!

  • BoxersForLife

    I swear sometimes old people can be cold. One little problem and they want
    to put their animals down. Should start putting them down so I can have some social security when I get that old.

  • sss

    If only the pit bulls were treated the same! ;( Blame the deed NOT the breed

  • http://topsy.com/sacramento.cbslocal.com/2011/01/26/shelter-gives-away-dog-marked-for-euthanization/?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention Shelter Gives Away Dog Marked For Euthanization « CBS Sacramento — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by CBS13 Sacramento, Doreen , Sam Davis, littlebabyleroy, lisa gonzales and others. lisa gonzales said: RT @CBS13rightnow: Owner gives dog to shelter for euthanization; shelter gives dog away. http://bit.ly/h4KKqq [...]

  • reader

    In fairness to old people, the article does not mention the original owner by name or give their age. ON THE OTHER HAND, the man who adopted the dog is 81.

  • Jeane Miller

    Thank you, El Dorado County Animal Shelter for saving this darling dog…..How nice to know that there are people with a heart for our animal friends who cannot speak for themselves.

  • JP

    I so agree sss. If that had been a pit they wouldnt have thought twice. I am happy that they did find the dog a new home though.

  • Jackie Hobbs

    Fantastic work, El Dorado County Animal Shelter!
    You not only saved that adorable dog’s life, but made an 81 year old man much happier, and I’m glad to see that the shelter intervened!

  • Rene Walker

    Thank goodness someone was paying attention!!! Bless you all who saved this dogs life. She is adorable and I bet she loves her new owner.
    GOOD WORK El Dorado Animal Shelter…..I will have to send in a donation
    for your good work!!!!!!

  • Britt

    Thank you El Dorado County Animal Shelter and Sophie’s adopter! We have a healthy, happy 2 year old German Shepherd…she has issues with incontinence. You know what she does? She takes a pill!! Two times a day, not difficult. The fact that some people have so little regard for their animals disgusts me. I’m glad Sophie when to someone that will love her!

  • Rescue Rep

    Good JOb EDC Shelter for using common sense that the orig. owner obviously didn’t have….Hello…Its called training…If you dont have patience, dont take care of a pet…

  • Michelle

    amen sss!!

  • Melissa in NorCal

    Uh no….a pit bull would not have been adopted out as easily and a 81 year old would have been insane to adopt a pit bull. The deed is bred into the breed you fool.

  • Nance

    I had a dog that was incontinent A single pill once a week resolved the situation immediately. To put a wonderful family pet to sleep for that reason is absolutely disturbing to me. My current dog is 9 years old and she is also incontinent. I would no more even think of hurting her by putting her to sleep than my worst enemy, if I had one. The Animal Shelter did exactly what they are there for……….to help an animal who needs one to speak out for them………..Congrats to El Dorado Animal Shelter

  • MrsOsuna

    Animal Shelters should evaluate the animals that they get in. The most likely issue was that the woman didn’t take the dog out to the bathroom enough, not incontinence. It happens. I worked for one of the local animal shelters and people would bring in animals all of the time because the animals were unwanted, not because they were sick and dying. The fact that so many animals are in shelters is proof of that. I can’t believe the original owner had the nerve to complain.

  • MrsOsuna

    That’s not true. I’ve known many well behaved and loving pits. I’ve seen thousands of them working in the Veterinary field. Statistically you’re more likely to be bitten by a small dog than a pit. A it due to it’s anatomy will do more damage though.

  • lindahareid

    Good Job Animal Control. Shame on you original owner! Could the bladder problem be from the inability to go outside due to the owner not training the dog because it took effort! Thank goodness for the senior gentlemen, what a great companion they will be for each other.

  • Britt

    Just to clarify: our dog gets out all of the time to go to the bathroom, she just dribbled a bit before she started her pills, vet told us that it was likely something that happened when she was spayed.

  • alohamom

    EDC Animal Shelter — You absolutely did the right thing! Thanks

  • Erin

    Thank you MrsOsuna. Not sure why people don’t understant that. APBTs were bread to fight and take down large animals….not small ones or humans. So idon’t let your pit loose in a field of cows then! People need to understand that it is a relativley rare occurance that I pit bull “attacks” a human and in those cases, the owners were usually being irresponsible. If I saw my dog had never been proper socialized and trained and/or displayed one once of human aggression, I would take EVERY percaussion to keep him away from people. As it is, due to his anatomy and the fact that once cannot predict what might pervoke ANY dog to bite, I keep him on a short leesh, he’s well trianed and NEVER is left in the yard unsupervised.

  • Erin

    Ugh…..so true. We rescued a pit bull from going to the SPCA where he likely would have been put down. He was found on the street in the hood, dying. Best dog ever! He’s smart and so he’s been very easy to train….he’s loving and friendly to EVERYONE! I wish people would understand that most of them, like most other dogs, when properly trained and socialized are great dogs!

  • Dot Baxter

    More shelters should follow the lead of El Dorado. The adoption sounds like a good match. I had a dog that was incontinent for her entire life of 13 yrs because of irresponsible puppy mill breeding. I was offered the option to return her and they would have put her to sleep. I chose instead to treat her condition and with meds and acupuncture she lived a full and loving life. Every dog deserves a chance! The type of people who would do this to their faithful companion are probably no more compassionate to their parents! I am now Mom to 5 rescues and each of them have their issues, but don’t we all? Rescue & Adopt!!!

  • Little Eagle

    She didn’t want the full responsibility and yet didn’t want anyone to have the pet. Selfish and cruel, the dog isn’t ready to die, hurray for the shelter.

  • Shelter Volunteer

    Wow….She’d rather the dog be euthanized than to have a loving home? Unreal.
    I think the shelter did the right thing here but should add something to their surrender forms about evaluation for potential adoption and refunding of euthanization fees over surrender fees if the pet is deemed adoptable.

  • Karin

    For once a shelter gets it right! Good for you Mr. Brzezinski!! AND a state agency WILLINGLY refunds the difference to the former owner! Bravo! I would be willing to place a substantial amount of money that this dog wasn’t incontinent. My bet would go toward the owner being to lazy to take the time to take him/her out and dedicate the time to potty train the pup. What a great example of what a disgustingly disposable society we have become!

  • Cris Alarcon

    A Few errors in this story: A Placerville resident, not Placer County, but El Dorado County. The family that now has the dog also is experiencing an incontanence problem diagnosed as a bladder infection. Not unusual for these things to be a cronic problem that comes and goes.

  • brenda

    My beloved English Mastif has had the same problem since she was spayed, I would not even consider putting Moe down any more than my own childrejn. I can’t believe the original owner would even show her face.

  • Cayce Wallace

    Good for the shelter staff! I wonder if they asked the woman if they could adopt it out vs putting it to sleep if she would have said yes…. and if she said no that would have been a death sentence, so I say more power to you shelter staff!

  • http://botd.wordpress.com/2011/01/28/top-posts-1734/ Top Posts — WordPress.com

    [...] Shelter Gives Away Dog Marked For Euthanization PLACERVILLE, Calif. (CBS13) – A Placer County resident who asked for her dog to be put to sleep because of health [...] [...]

  • Dukie Ippolito

    God Bless that Shelter Staff,I had a German Sherpard mixand he was 10 years old with a lot of Health problems, The vet said it was just a matter of time, He was so surprised when we took him back 6 years later.My friends said you are going to put him to sleep (I HATE THAT WORD PUT HIM DOWN) I said I would put my husband to sleep before I would put my Dog.to sleep lol My late husband always said in every man’s life he should have 1 good dog and 1 good woman said he I have the dog. lol P.S> I DID NOT PUT MY LATE HISBAND TO SLEEP LOL

  • judith

    I agree completely. I’v heard lots of people say training their dog is difficult only to watch and see the owners need trained not the dog.

  • C in the midwest

    My God what a disposable world we live in when a poor innocent creature who has harmed no one can be summarily dismissed by unfeeling owners, who don’t wish to deal with the flaws that sometimes come with a pet. Good for the shelter that they saw a chance to give the animal a new life and a new home with someone who wouldn’t mind the extra care it may need. First the animals…then the elderly, then the children…who will be left to say No more?

  • Tracy Gunnels Crossposter

    WAY TO GO EDC ANIMAL SHELTER! After all the really bad press I see every day with supposed shelters killing dozens of animals a day, it’s such a breath of fresh air to hear of one doing something RIGHT!

    I wonder who’s going to take care of that old biddy when she becomes incontinent? I hope no one! I wish her a really bad, painful, and lonely life!

  • Dianne M. Kurtz

    A minor peeing issue is something that can be controlled.I am so glad Sophie got adopted.Her owner should be ashamed of him/herself for wanting her dog to be put down.

  • Cathy Ramsey

    So glad El Dorado County adopted that little dog out. That woman should be ashamed of herself for taking a penny back from the shelter. I do cat rescue and it still amazes me the stories these horrid people come up with to dispose of their precious pets.

  • susan taylor

    great job guys, bravo finally a shelter that actually tries to save the special needs dogs that are marked for execution, super

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS Sacramento